Lesbians and Depression
Ellen Haller, MD
UCSF School of Medicine
The WomenCare Mental Health Clinic
What is depression?
Depression
is not the same as “The
Blues.” In depression, down times last longer and symptoms are both
emotional and physical. One can’t simply “snap out of it” and may
often feel completely hopeless and have thoughts of suicide. Functioning
is often impaired.
Many myths exist about depression,
however, it is not:
Following are the diagnostic criteria for
Major Depression:
A. Five (or more) of the following
symptoms have been present during the same two-week period on nearly
every day and represent a change from previous functioning. At least
one of the symptoms is either depressed mood or loss of interest or
pleasure.
-
Depressed mood most of the day
-
Markedly decreased interest or
pleasure in activities most of the day
-
Decrease or increase in appetite
-
Decrease or increase in sleep
-
Restlessness or decreased activity
-
Fatigue or loss of energy
-
Feelings of worthlessness or
excessive or inappropriate guilt
-
Decreased concentration or
indecisiveness
-
Recurrent thoughts of death or
suicide
B. Symptoms are not a mixed episode
of Bipolar Disorder (also known as Manic Depression).
C. The symptoms cause clinically
significant distress or impairment in social, occupational or other
important areas of functioning.
D. The symptoms are not due to a
general medical condition or a substance (including prescribed, over
the counter, or illicit drugs).
E. The symptoms are not better
accounted for by bereavement (they last more than two months after
the death of a loved one).
Â
How Common is Major Depression?
Depression is a common illness with
significant cost to individuals and to society. The total annual cost
estimate (both direct and indirect costs) is $43.7 billion in the United
States. The first episode of major depression usually occurs in the 20s
or 30s age ranges, although it can occur at any age. After one episode
of major depression, there is a 50% risk of a subsequent episode. This
risk increases to 70% after two episodes, and after three or more
episodes, the recurrence rate is 90%.
Overall,
rates of depression in post-pubertal women are twice the
rates in men. It’s estimated that
approximately 20% of all women will have at least one episode of major
depression in their lifetimes.
Explanations
for the gender difference are numerous. Social stressors
such as women’s increased vulnerability
to domestic violence and rape, their typically lower wages compared with
male counterparts, lower social status and the resultant financial
difficulties can contribute to the development of depression.
Life cycle and developmental issues are
crucial as well, such as the multiple roles juggled by women throughout
their lives including mother, spouse and worker. Women who are mothers
of preschool children have been shown to have the highest rates of
stress. However, women with adolescents and those at mid-life whose
children are out of the home also have the potential to develop
psychiatric symptoms in response to their changing roles. Although the
developmental tasks of young women, women of child-bearing age, those at
mid-life and older women are different, all must cope with balancing
their multiple roles.
Â
How Common is Depression in Lesbians?
The definitive answer to this question
remains unclear. In addition to the risk factors for depression in women
listed above, lesbians and bisexual women may be more at risk for
developing depression.
Living
in a homophobic society, facing possible rejection from
one’s family, not having equal legal
recognition of relationships, being closeted in some (or all) aspects of
one’s life, using substances abusively, and lacking equal health
insurance benefits - all are risk factors for depression in lesbians
and bisexual women.
The true prevalence of depression in this
population is not clear. Some studies have found higher rates of
depression in lesbians compared to heterosexual women, but others have
not.
Â
Components of Depression Treatment
Although a common symptom of depression
is feeling hopeless that it will ever go away, depression is a treatable
condition. Components of depression treatment include a thorough
evaluation, education and self-help, individual or group talk therapy
and sometimes the prescription of antidepressant medications. Treatment
should begin with a thorough evaluation to rule out an underlying
medical condition or the side effect of medications as the cause of the
depression symptoms. For example, thyroid illness may initially present
with depression.
Some behavioral steps one can take to
help combat depression include setting realistic goals, breaking tasks
into small pieces, spending time with others, being physically active,
avoiding drugs and alcohol consumption, being patient about the rate of
improvement and avoiding making major life decisions. Helpful books
include Feeling Good by David Burns and Queer Blues: The
Lesbian and Gay Guide to Overcoming Depression by Hall and Hardin.
Two specific types of psychotherapy have
been proven effective in treating depression. These are (1)
cognitive-behavioral (CBT) and (2) interpersonal (IPT) therapy.
CBT focuses on the cognitive triad of
depression: a negative view of the self, the world, and the future. In
the therapy, one learns about distorted thoughts that contribute to
depression and about how to challenge the veracity of these thoughts, to
develop alternatives and to increase flexibility. CBT is usually
time-limited, i.e. 12 sessions total and can be done individually or in
a group setting.
In interpersonal psychotherapy (IPT), one
focuses on relationships, current issues and social functioning using an
educational approach. IPT is usually time-limited (often 12-16 weekly
individual sessions) and includes ongoing maintenance visits less
frequently.
Medications including herbs, supplements
and prescription antidepressants can be helpful in treating depression.
Herbs and supplements are not regulated by FDA, and there is no
guarantee that they are pure, safe, and effective. Very little is known
regarding interactions with other similar products or with prescription
or over-the-counter drugs, and their safety in pregnancy or with
breastfeeding unknown.
Many
people are hesitant to take prescription antidepressants
because they fear becoming “addicted”
or are frightened by the stigma or by the many media stories such as the
reports of Prozac’s potential to make people violent or suicidal
(which has since been definitively disproved). Some individuals are
hesitant to take these medications because they associate them with
illicit drugs such as amphetamines or cocaine which artificially and
temporarily elevate mood.
Prescription
antidepressants are not addictive and do not cause a “high.” Several
different classes are available, and all appear to be equally
effective. Typically, response
to an antidepressant may take four to six weeks, and once a response
is achieved, it is recommended that the medication be continued
for an
additional nine to twelve months of feeling good. Stopping the
medication sooner may result in a relapse back into the depression. For
those who have had several bouts of depression, long-term treatment with
medication is the most effective means of preventing recurring episodes.
Where to get help
If you are unsure where to go for help,
ask your family doctor, OB/GYN physician, or health clinic for
assistance. You can also check the Yellow Pages under "mental health," "health," "social
services," "suicide prevention," "crisis
intervention services," "hotlines," "hospitals"
or "physicians" for phone numbers and addresses. In times of
crisis, the emergency room clinicians may be able to provide temporary
help for an emotional problem and will be able to tell you where and
how to get further help.
The Association of Gay and Lesbian
Psychiatrists (www.aglp.org) and the Gay and Lesbian
Medical Association (www.glma.org) can help with referrals. Your
insurance company can also be a referral source; many managed care plans
actually require that they be contacted by you if you are in need of a
mental health referral before you schedule an appointment with a
clinician.
Conclusions
Depression is a common problem with significant
morbidity and mortality and may affect lesbians more frequently
than heterosexual women. Depression is more than just feeling tired of
blue. Multiple options exist for treatment of this condition, and the
decision about what treatment to pursue depends on the severity of
symptoms, past history, family history, and individual preference. A
critical message to retain is that depression
is treatable!
Â
Additional Resources
Association
of Gay and Lesbian Psychiatrists
http://www.aglp.orgÂ
Gay
and Lesbian Medical Association
http://www.glma.orgÂ
U.S.
Public Health Service Office of Women’s Health
http://www.4woman.org/owhÂ
National
Institute of Mental Health Depression Information (specifically for
women)
http://www.nimh.nih.gov/publicat/depwomenknows.cfmÂ
Depression
After Delivery (organization for women with post-partum depression)
http://www.depressionafterdelivery.comÂ
National
Foundation for Depressive Illness
800-248-4344
http://www.depression.orgÂ
National
Depression and Manic Depressive Association
312-642-0049
http://www.ndmda.orgÂ
|